Is your cat shedding excessively, leaving you overwhelmed with furballs and loose hair? This review dives into the world of cat brushes, tackling the challenge of managing a cat's seasonal shedding. With a double-coated cat experiencing extreme shedding, I put four different brushes to the test: the renowned Furminator, a novel sickle-shaped brush, a classic rubber brush, and a slicker brush with protective tips. My goal was to discover which brush, or combination of brushes, proved most effective at managing excessive shedding and maintaining a healthy, comfortable coat for my feline companion. The results may surprise you!This comprehensive review details the performance of each brush, analyzing its effectiveness on both undercoat and topcoat, as well as assessing my cat's comfort level during the grooming process. From tackling stubborn mats to removing loose fur and smoothing the coat, we'll explore the strengths and weaknesses of each brush, ultimately determining the best approach to daily grooming for a cat with a thick, double coat. Whether your cat has mats, excessive undercoat, or just needs a regular brushing, this review offers valuable insights to help you find the "purrfect" tool for your furry friend.
Pros And Cons
- Helps cut through mats
- Straightens fur
- May not be effective without mats
Read more: 5 Best Double-Sided Cat Brushes: Top Picks Reviewed
The Shedding Problem & Brush Lineup
My cat's seasonal shedding was getting out of control. Hairballs the size of my thumb were a daily occurrence, and weekly brushing wasn't cutting it. Daily brushing became a necessity. To tackle this, I decided to review several cat brushes.

My collection included four different brushes: the Furminator, a new sickle-shaped brush (for mats), a classic rubber brush, and a slicker brush with protected tips. I planned to test each brush on my cat to determine their effectiveness and compare their strengths and weaknesses.

Testing the Brushes: Furminator & Sickle Brush
I started with the Furminator, a familiar and popular choice. My cat seemed comfortable with it. It effectively removed a good amount of undercoat. However, he required breaks during this process.

Next, I tried the new sickle-shaped brush, designed for tackling mats. My cat doesn't currently have mats, so I couldn't fully assess its mat-cutting capabilities. However, it seemed gentle on his coat and removed some loose fur. The unique design was intriguing, promising efficient detangling for cats with matted fur.

Rubber & Slicker Brush Results
The rubber brush proved excellent for picking up the remaining tiny bits of fur missed by the other brushes. This made it a useful complement to the other brushes in my collection. It was also very gentle on my cat's skin.

The slicker brush, with its protected tips, was also well-received by my cat and did a great job at removing loose hair and smoothing his coat. This brush worked well for both the undercoat and the topcoat.

Conclusion: A Multi-Brush Approach
My cat has a double coat, requiring different brushes to address both the undercoat and the overcoat effectively. The Furminator was great for removing undercoat, the sickle brush showed promise for mat removal, and both the rubber and slicker brushes were useful in removing surface fur and smoothing his coat.

For optimal results, a combination of brushes seems to be the key. No single brush is perfect for all purposes and all cat breeds. Considering my cat's reaction and the effectiveness of each brush, it is worth having a variety on hand for daily grooming. The sickle brush is certainly beneficial if your cat has matted fur, while the others are useful for maintaining overall coat health.
